
There are many myths and stories about experiences in the Otherworld realm that we call the “underworld.”
Time spent in this place is uniquely transformative. Something dies in that parallel realm and yet this isn’t necessarily gruesome, or extraordinarily difficult and painful. In some instances, pain and difficulty in this world is what precipitates a descent into the underworld.
Such is the case in the fairytale “Mother Holle.” This story offers us an interesting perspective on the underworld experience and the possibilities we might uncover there.
Thanks for listening, and keep the mystery in your life alive.
Transcript of Underworld experiences: “Mother Holle” fairytale
creativity and consciousness. I’m your host Dr. Catherine Svehla. Wherever you may be in this wide beautiful crazy world of ours, I’m glad that you decided to join me here today.
I shared some ideas about the underworld with you last month, and told a fairy tale about an underworld experience that you may not have seen through this lens. There are many myths and stories about experiences in the “Otherworld” realm that we call the “underworld.” Time spent in this place is uniquely transformative. Something dies in that parallel realm and yet this isn’t necessarily gruesome, or extraordinarily difficult and painful. In some instances, pain and difficulty in this world is what precipitates a descent into the underworld.
I think it’s more useful to view the underworld as a place of reversal or, as C.G. Jung described it, “enantiodromia,” which means “running to the opposite.” This Jungian concept points to the psychic need for evolution or growth through a retrieval of lost values and the establishment of a new inner harmony.
So, the transformation that takes place in the underworld is the result of a revelation of a previously hidden truth of some sort. Hidden in the foreign darkness of the underworld. Wealth and life that we must recover for ourselves. When we contact this truth about ourselves or our lives, we are transformed. The old self, the self that did not know this truth, has died.
Thinking about the underworld experience in this way broadens our awareness of this dynamic in the psyche and I think it helps us see more of the potential in the experience. I have another fairy tale for you today that speaks to these themes. The story is “Mother Holle.” My version is based on the story collected by the Grimm Brothers, who called it “Frau Holle.” Variations and closely related tales can be found in other cultural traditions.
Now, I invite you to relax and listen. Let yourself be carried on the current of the story. There’s no need to figure anything out but it is useful to notice the detail or moment that snags your attention. This might be something that puzzles you, or that you especially like or dislike. Your response to the story is a clue to the place these themes occupy in your life right now.
Mother Holle

A widow had two daughters. One was beautiful and industrious, the other ugly and lazy. She greatly favored the ugly, lazy girl, because she was her own daughter. The other one, the stepdaughter, had to do all the work of the house.
Every day, the poor girl had to go sit by a well near the roadside and spin for so long that her fingers bled. One day it happened that her spindle was covered with blood, so she went over to the well to rinse it off. The spindle slipped out of her hands and fell all the way down to the bottom of the well. The girl burst into tears and ran home to tell the stepmother about her misfortune. The woman scolded her mercilessly and was so nasty that, in the end, she told her: “If you let the spindle drop into the well, then go back and get it.“
The girl went back to the well and did not know what to do. Terrified, she finally jumped into the well to get the spindle. She lost consciousness down at the bottom. When she came to herself again, she was lying in a beautiful meadow. The sun was shining, and there were thousands of beautiful flowers all around.
The girl wandered around the meadow and in the middle she came upon an oven full of bread. The bread called out, “Oh, take me out. Take me out, or I’ll burn. I’ve been thoroughly baked for a long time.” So, the girl went to the oven and carefully lifted out the loaves, one at a time and laid them in the grass.
The girl walked further and came to a tree whose branches were laden with apples. “Shake me. Shake me. All of my apples are ripe,” cried the tree. The girl shook the tree until the all the apples fell as if it were raining fruit. When none were left on the tree, she gathered the apples into a pile and continued on her way.
Finally, the girl came to a small house. An old woman was peering out the window at her. The old woman had very large teeth, which frightened the girl, and she wanted to run away. But the old woman called out to her, “What are you afraid, of dear child. Stay here with me, and if you do my housework in an orderly fashion, you won’t be sorry. But you must take care to make my bed well and diligently shake the eiderdown until the feathers fly. Then snow will fall on the earth. I am called Mother Holle.”

The old woman spoke so gently and kindly to her, that the girl took heart and agreed to work for her. She completed all of her chores, day after day. The girl took care of everything to Mother Holle’s satisfaction and always shook her featherbed vigorously until the feathers flew about like snowflakes. In return, her life was not unpleasant. There were no angry words, and she had boiled or roast meat every day.
The girl had been living with Mother Holle for a time, when she became sad. At first she didn’t know what was the matter but eventually she realized that she was homesick. Even though she was much, much, much better off with Mother Holle than she was at home, she had a yearning to return. Finally, she told Mother Holle, “I have such a longing for home, even though I am very well off here. I cannot stay any longer. I have to see my family again.”
Mother Holle wasn’t angry. “I understand your longing for your home, ” she told the girl, “and because you have served me so faithfully, I will take you back myself.” With that she took the girl by the hand and led her to a large gate. The gate opened and when the girl passed through it, she was showered with gold. The gold stuck to her and she was completely covered with it. from head to toe. “That’s your reward for working so hard,” said Mother Holle. Then she handed the girl the spindle that had fallen into the well. Then the gate was closed and the girl found herself above on earth, not far from her mother’s house.
When she entered the yard a rooster was perched on the well crowing:
Cock-a-doodle-doo, cock-a-doodle-doo,
Golden girl is here and she’s well-to-do.
The girl went inside to her mother, and as she was all covered with gold, she was well received both by her mother and her sister. The girl told them all that had happened to her, and when the mother learned how she had come to the great wealth, she was anxious to bring the same good fortune to the ugly and lazy daughter. She told her to go sit by the well and start spinning.
The lazy girl took a spindle and went to the well. She pricked her fingers in a hedge of thorns to make them bloody. Then she threw the spindle into the well and jumped in herself.
Like her sister, she found herself in the beautiful meadow. When she came to the oven, the bread cried again, “Oh, take me out. Take me out, or else I’ll burn. I’ve been thoroughly baked for a long time.” But the lazy girl answered, “As if I would want to get all dirty,” and walked away.
Soon she came to the apple tree, which called out to her, “Oh, shake me. Shake me. All of my apples are ripe.” But she answered, “What are you thinking? One could fall on my head,” and with that she walked on.

When she arrived at Mother Holle’s house, she was not afraid because she had already heard about her large teeth. She received the same instruction and immediately began to work for the old woman.
On the first day she forced herself and worked hard at every task she was assigned. She really wanted all of that gold. On the second day, she began to take things a bit easier. On the third day, she didn’t even want to get out of bed. She even refused to make Mother Holle’s bed as she had promised, forgetting that she was supposed to shake the eiderdown until the feathers flew all around.
Mother Holle soon became tired of this and dismissed her from her duties. This was just what the lazy girl wanted, for she thought that she would now get the rain of gold.
Mother Holle led her to the gate. It opened and the girl passed through but instead of gold, a large kettle full of pitch spilled over her.
“That is the reward for your services,” said Mother Holle, and closed the gate. The lazy girl went home, entirely covered with pitch. When the rooster at the well saw her, he cried out:
Cock-a-doodle-doo, cock-a-doodle-doo,
Tar-girl is here and she needs a shampoo.
But the pitch stuck fast to her, and did not come off as long as she lived.
When fairy tales became stories for children, they were often tweaked to be vehicles for moral instruction. This story has been used as a tool to reinforce the message that good girls are dutiful, obedient, and work hard in the home. A message that is rightly criticized today, given the lack of value placed on what is seen as “women’s work” and the patriarchal expectation that a woman will sacrifice herself to labor unceasingly on behalf of others.
But is this story merely a vehicle for this tired message? The story is titled Frau or Mother Holle, after the mysterious woman in the underworld/otherworld. And our protagonist, the industrious and compassionate girl, is independently wealthy at the end of the story. She doesn’t need to do household chores or serve anyone else if she doesn’t want to.
The girl in this story has the capacity to work hard and the skill to complete many domestic tasks. She’s also compassionate and “beautiful,” fairy tale language for “an exemplary person.” And gold symbolizes more than money. Gold is the perfected essence, the self-fulfillment at the end of an alchemical process. Gold is the currency of the sovereign and she receives it from the mysterious Mother Holle.
I appreciate the presence of a herald in this story, in the form of a red rooster perched on the well who announces the return of both sisters. Roosters are a male energy associated with the Sun. Sun- again, we have the Gold. The rooster announces the end of night– and nightmares– and the arrival of a new dawn. Our rooster tells us that this is a rebirth into a truer form for both of the girls, and we need some male energy to balance all the women in this story!
I want to say more about the figure of Mother Holle and a good starting place is a Greco-Roman myth this fairy tale brings to mind, the myth of Psyche and Eros. The girl begins her story in a situation similar to Psyche’s. She’s in a place where her strength and gifts are not properly appreciated and even cause her suffering. A transformation is necessary, a rite of passage. The bloody spindle reinforces this idea. The moment of stepping over the threshold– or jumping into the well— arrives after much difficulty and sacrifice.
Like Psyche, our industrious girl is full of fear and despair and decides to take an action that she believes will likely result in her death. Psyche is left on a mountaintop to meet a monster. The girl jumps into the well. The story doesn’t explicitly say that she’s imagining death but we’re told that she’s terrified, and what else could you expect? When you’re all alone and jump into a well, how do you plan to get out?
After these brave actions, both female characters wake up or come to consciousness to discover that they are alive and in a beautiful meadow. The meadow is part of a different world and a home situation that’s a vast improvement over the one they left. They meet a kind benefactor who values them. And yet in both stories, something is missing. An initiation must take place, followed by a return to the problem posed at the beginning of the story. Only now, there’s a solution. The solution is the transformed young woman herself.
In our fairytale, the young woman wants to go home although she’s much better off in the underworld/otherworld. Mother Holle doesn’t stop her because her initiation, the successful completion of the required tasks, is done. The girl responded to the bread and the apple tree, both of whom spoke to her of readiness and right timing, and she did what was necessary and compassionate. The girl faithfully executed her chores, day after day.

Now, the young woman needs to return as someone who is properly recognized, valued, and rewarded in order to complete her transformation. And the value or truth represented by the young woman is needed in her old world. That world needs to change too. The world that views kindness and industriousness as an opportunity for exploitative servitude. That equates greed and cheating with cleverness, and may not even appreciate the difference. And it does.
Now, who is Mother Holle, this story’s namesake? Elements in the story point to her association with the goddess, the source of life and death, and the catalyst behind the cycle of transformation. Bread and apples point to grains and harvest, household and the abundance of the earth. Apples also symbolize love. The reference to snow links Mother Holle to earth goddesses who control the weather and seasonal cycles. This mother is mother to all. She’s known by many names. What comes to mind for me is the Greek Demeter, whose daughter Persephone became Queen of the Underworld.
The spindle is also important. Spinning and weaving link this story to the Goddess. To the Fates who spin and measure and cut, and the many other female deities who are skilled at the craft of weaving– weaving the fabric of the world, weaving story, weaving meaning– as well as weaving cloth. The spindle symbolizes the domestic art and time-consuming crafts that have been the burden and joy of so many women around the world for centuries. A “distaff” is a cleft staff that holds unspun fiber and is a tool used in spinning. Today, “distaff” also refers to something female, the female side of a family, for example. The connection between the Goddess, women, and weaving as magic and craft, is old and deep.
What was our young woman really spinning with her cut and bloody fingers? Were the abuse and admonitions of her stepmother her only motivation? Or was there something stirring deep within her, deeper than she could know when the story began, some question, intention, or hope when she took the spindle to the well to wash it off and let it drop?
Only the ones living this story know the answer.
I have a final thought about this, but first a big welcome to new email subscribers: Samuel, Elan, Charles, Cole, Gail Lynn, Jen, Ann, Teresa, Mary Lou, Debbie, Helyn and Bob. Welcome to Myth Matters!
If you’d like to receive links to new Myth Matters episodes in your inbox, sign up at my Mythic Mojo website. Email subscribers also receive my monthly newsletter and are the first to learn about new offerings and resources I have to share.
I’m perpetually grateful for my supporters on Patreon and bandcamp who offer financial and community support to the podcast. The reciprocity means a lot to me and it’s the foundation of sustainable community. Thank you, my friends. If you’re finding something of value in Myth Matters, I hope that you’ll support the work in whatever form makes sense for you. Share an episode, post a positive review, join my Patreon, or send me an email so I know you’re out there. I’d love to hear from you. Thank you!
Now back to those big questions for a moment before we part ways. Spinning a thread to weave into fabric, perhaps this is the thread of a life story, the fabric of a life. This spinning and weaving is often a difficult task. The underworld suffering we imagine may be present in our daily lives in this world, in the effort required to develop skill, to work hard, to keep going without recognition or reward. Do we see only the literal work of it and miss the daily building of the self that takes place? Or do we try, like the lazy sister, to get the gold the easy way, to collect the rewards for a self that we couldn’t be bothered to build, to scramble after a literal wealth without understanding where the value truly lies?
So many possibilities in the metaphors of spindle, the thread, the fiber, the bloody fingers. What do you think? What do they signify for you?

And what moves us to the well and the risky decision to jump into the unknown rite of passage? That leap is rarely, if ever, something we manage on our own. Outer circumstances, desperation, and urgency can send us to the well. But then? There is something deep in the psyche that knows when the loaves are baked and the apples are ripe and we are ready to be initiated. If you feel the necessity for deep change but lack the clarity or courage, you can attend to what is moving in your depths and ask to be willing.
There’s never a guarantee. But Mother Holle may be waiting for you, in that little house in the meadow.
If we have a better understanding of our need for myth, and all that our old stories offer, we can live more satisfying lives. We can inhabit a better story and create a more beautiful, just, and life-centered, life-embracing world.
And that’s it for me, Catherine Svehla and Myth Matters. Take good care of yourself my friend, and until next time, keep the mystery in your life alive.
Leave a Reply